Pregraded

How to find card comps

A comp is a recent sale of the same card in the same condition. Good comps are the difference between pricing a card right and leaving money on the table.

3 min read Updated

Card Comps CalculatorFind what a card recently sold for, then turn the sales into a fair price.Open the tool

What counts as a comp

A comp is a completed sale, not a listing. Asking prices tell you what sellers hope for; sold prices tell you what buyers paid. To count, a sale has to be the same card in the same condition:

  • Same card: year, brand, set, card number and player.
  • Same version: base, parallel, numbered, autograph or insert. Parallels can sell for many times the base card.
  • Same condition: raw cards compare with raw cards, and graded cards with the same grade from the same company. A PSA 9 and a BGS 9 often sell for different prices.

Where to look

eBay is the biggest source of card sales. Search the card, then filter to sold items so you only see completed sales, newest first. The card comps calculator builds that search for you, adds the grade, and leaves out lots, reprints and breaks.

Auction houses and grading companies publish results too, which helps for high-end cards that rarely sell on eBay. For everyday cards, eBay sold listings are the most complete picture.

Spotting bad comps

  • Best offers. When a listing sold through "Best offer accepted", eBay shows the asking price, and the buyer paid less.
  • Wrong card. Titles stuffed with keywords can show up for the wrong parallel or year. Check the photo.
  • Damaged or altered cards. A raw card with a crease or a trimmed edge sells far below a clean one.
  • Odd outliers. A sale far above every other one can be a shill bid or an unpaid item. One far below can be a mislabeled listing.

The calculator flags sales that sit far outside the normal range and leaves them out, but it's worth a quick look at each one yourself.

Turning sales into a price

Don't use the highest sale, and don't use the average if one sale is wild. The middle sale, the median, is the safest single number. From there:

  • To sell fast, price near the lower quarter of recent sales.
  • To get full value, price near the middle.
  • If you can wait, list near the upper quarter and accept offers.

Weight recent sales more. Card prices move with a player's season, news and new releases, so a sale from last week beats one from six months ago.

When there are only a few sales

Rare parallels and low-population graded cards may have one or two sales a year. Widen the search a little: look at the grade above and below, nearby serial numbers, or the same parallel of a similar player. Treat the result as a range, not a single price.

Questions

How many comps do I need?

Five or more recent sales give a reliable middle. With fewer than four, treat the number as a rough guide.

Should I include shipping in the comp?

Use the item price. Shipping charges vary by seller and don't change what the card itself is worth.

How far back should I look?

The last 30 to 90 days for most cards. Go further back only when there aren't enough recent sales, and remember older prices may be stale.

Sources

Card Comps CalculatorFind what a card recently sold for, then turn the sales into a fair price.Open the tool

Keep reading